Best Sandwiches in Suffern, NY

Bagel Boys Café 🥯

Welcome to Bagel Boys Café, serving breakfast and lunch for over 30 years at 7 North Airmont Road, Suffern, NY. 📌Our café boasts old-school charm and fresh, hand-rolled New York-style bagels made daily. But we offer more than bagels—enjoy our sandwiches, omelets, pancakes, and bakery treats like rugelach, cookies, and muffins. Plus, our rich, smooth coffee is always ready to go.

Good Food, Made Simple

We know life gets busy, so we’ve kept things simple. You can enjoy our food wherever you are with our easy delivery and pickup options. Hosting an event? Our catering platters are made with care and perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast or lunch, we make sure it’s easy and convenient.

Feels Like Home

When you walk into Bagel Boys Café, you’ll feel at home. Our cozy spot has plenty of seating, so you can relax and enjoy your meal. Whether you’re here with friends, family, or just by yourself, we’re here to make your day a little brighter. Can’t stay? No problem—order online and take Bagel Boys with you.

Keeping It Real

For over 30 years, we’ve been a part of the Suffern community, serving up good, honest food with a smile. We’re proud to keep the tradition going and can’t wait to share it with you. So, come visit us today, or order online and let us be part of your day.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Bagels always fresh. The atmosphere is pretty cool. Your order is taken Great follow through on the orders. And the food does take a few seconds to prepare because it's prepared fresh for the customer which is always a great thing. And the food taste amazing so I recommend this place if you're in the area.

James Darren H.

First timer, ordered online. Two bagels were ready on time. Upon opening the foil I knew it was going to be amazing. Flagel was toasted to perfection, eggs were amazing, cheese melt and perfect amount of ketchup. What can ofentimes be greasy and a bit heavy was completely the opposite here. Tasted fresh, no grease just delicious flavors. Blown away.

Kelly W.

A great local place for breakfast sandwiches, breads, pastries, bagels, coffee, subs, wraps, sandwiches, and a full deli counter. Good prices too... Definitely gonna visit again next time I'm in the area.